Anne and Mark have gone on a few travels in the past year or so. Usually, people who learn of their travel plans express excitement and wish them a safe journey. Every once in a while, a person will express surprise or even dismay - why would you want to go THERE? Fair enough. But, never has anyone ever said, specifically and without equivocation, "You should not go there." Until now.
After their first trip to Jerusalem, Anne, Mark and the other faculty members in Tel Aviv decided that their next trip would be to the West Bank. The West Bank is a geographical area containing some areas that are controlled by the Palestinian authorities. Jewish Israelis are not allowed to travel to portions of it, and Arab Palestinians who live in certain parts of it are not allowed to travel to other certain parts of it. For information about why this situation is as it is currently, please find further information in any newspaper published between 1948 and today.
Upon arriving in Israel, Anne and Mark were under the impression that the West Bank would be "off limits" to us for visits from a legal perspective. This is not the case. Americans are able to travel freely back and forth, assuming they have a guide who can get them where they are going. Our original guide was a Jewish man and an Israeli and was unable (and probably unwilling, even if able) to cross to the Palestinian controlled areas in the West Bank. Through a friend of a friend, Anne and Mark were able to secure another driver who was willing and able to take them to the Palestinian controlled areas of the West Bank.
Our friends who knew a thing or two about Israel told us that if we were going to go to the West Bank, which was not recommended, we should be careful. We could get robbed. Further, if we were lucky enough to make it back unscathed, we should not tell other Israelis that we had gone there. This would be very unpopular with the Israeli Jewish population.
Or, make it easy on yourself and just do not go there.
Mark Twain wrote, "Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry, and narrow-mindedness, and many of our people need it sorely on these accounts. Broad, wholesome, charitable views of men and things cannot be acquired by vegetating in one little corner of the earth all one's lifetime." (The Innocents Abroad) The sentiment behind this admonition is certainly one of the motivating factors for the travels of Anne and Mark. And lest any reader think that visiting the West Bank or not visiting the West Bank is a political action or an acceptance or rejection of the opinion of anyone who gave them advice, please remember what Mr. Clemens wrote in the quote above. Anne and Mark are not intending to pick sides, just intending to try to get a 'broad, wholesome and charitable view' of the people on each side.
That being said, although Anne and Mark have been in what used to be the 'Communist Bloc' for months now and actually have offices assigned to them in what was the Communist Party of Bulgaria's headquarters merely a quarter-century ago, they have never felt as 'foreign' as they did on the first stop of this day trip: the tomb and memorial of Yassar Arafat.
 |
| Arafat's home, where he served his house arrest and was under siege from time to time, is visible through the window behind the beefier soldier. Also - Romania forgot to type up their wreath measure. Oops. |
Yassar Arafat was the leader of the Palestinian Liberation Organization for years. He died a few years ago and is placed in this tomb near his former home/compound (partially visible in the photo above). Mr. Arafat asked to be buried in Jerusalem, but this request was denied by the authorities, so he is laid to rest in Ramallah. Everything that Anne and Mark had ever heard about Arafat has been negative, and the fact that he is treated with such reverence by the people of Palestine was a surprise. The fact that they were standing in a building within feet of the body of Mr. Arafat was quite a bit more surprising.
After this somewhat shocking first stop, Anne and Mark went into the city of Ramallah. The driver and guide, named Nadir, let the passengers out and they wandered around the town square. Anne spotted a familiar looking coffee shop, so Anne and Mark headed there for some java. Upon closer inspection, however, it was not a "Starbucks," but rather a "Stars and Bucks." Apparently, copyright enforcement in this part of the world is still in development. After picking up an iced coffee from Stars and Bucks, Anne and Mark wandered around the town square and spoke to a few merchants.
 |
| Excuse me, sir, which way to the Stars and Bucks? |
After spending a little time in Ramallah, the group loaded up the van again and headed to Hebron. Along the way Anne and Mark were able to observe new Israeli settlements built in the West Bank and the wall that is being built around them.
The area within the wall is a settlement controlled by the Israelis. The area outside the wall is controlled by the Palestinians. These settlements and the wall are a tremendous source of conflict between the Israelis and Palestinians at the current time.
Whether the wall is a wise move or not (several foreign governments appear to think it is not and have asked the Israelis to cease construction on it), construction continues. Anne and Mark can personally testify to this fact as part of the wall actually passed them on the highway on the road to Hebron.

After passing by the settlement, the wall, and a portion of the yet-to-be-constructed wall, the group arrived in Hebron. This city was among the more depressing places on the entire visit. Not that it needed to be depressing: Hebron is the home of the Cave of the Patriarchs and Matriarchs. According to tradition, Abraham purchased the cave for the purpose of burying his wife, Sarah. Currently, the site is the burial place of not only Sarah, but also Abraham himself, as well as Isaac, Rebekah, Jacob and Leah. It also has what is reported to be a cast of the footprint of Adam (some Muslims believe that Adam and Eve were sent to Hebron after being cast out of Eden). So this should be quite the joyous, holy place. The effect is quite the opposite.
There is a large structure built on top of the cave. The structure has been fought over through the years and an uneasy peace now exists. On one side of the building is the Jewish entrance. Through this entrance, visitors (assuming they are allowed to enter) can view the tombs of Abraham, Sarah, Jacob and
Leah. The entire side functions as a synagogue. The other side of the building has its own separate entrance. This side, controlled by the Muslims, contains a large mosque. Within the mosque are the tombs of Isaac and Rebekah. Israeli Jews are not allowed to visit the tombs of Isaac and Rebekah except on ten specified holidays each year. (tourists are allowed to enter either side every day)
At great risk of waxing philosophical, it was difficult to visit this site without thinking that the whole thing was a sad metaphor. Two of the world's great religions sprung from the same source, Abraham. The tomb of Abraham is a holy site for each of them and many of the devotees of each religions visit the site to pray. But each must enter the building form a different side. Each must view Abraham only from its own side. And because of the conflict, each is separated from getting closer to Abraham by prison bars.
After leaving the patriarchs and matriarchs, Anne and Mark visited a small shop outside. Inside the shop, the shopkeeper was making pottery. He had his potter's wheel going and he was throwing some pots while a small kiln was running at high temperatures nearby. Just as the shopkeeper in Jerusalem had done, this merchant invited us all in and served us tea.
After clearing out most of this shopkeeper's inventory (as is the custom of Anne and Mark when on holiday), they left for Bethlehem.